Troubleshooting check valve surges: slam analysis, closing speed diagnostics, and system transients

1. Problem description and scope

Pressure surges, also known as water hammers, occur when a column of fluid in a piping system is abruptly stopped or redirected. In check valves, this phenomenon typically occurs when the valve cone closes too quickly, which leads to an audible 'slam' (striking noise), massive pressure peaks and mechanical stress on the pipes. This guide addresses symptoms in industrial fluid systems, particularly in pump stations and distribution networks.

Severity classification:

• Critical: Audible thumps, visible pipe vibrations, flange leaks, repeated pressure switch alarms.
• Major: Pipe movements without immediate leakage, increased background noise when the pump stops.
• Minor: Occasional rattling of the valve cone when starting up.

2. Safety precautions

DANGER: Working on pipes under pressure. Before starting the diagnosis, depressurize the system, drain it and secure it with lockout/tagout (LOTO) in accordance with DIN EN 60204-1. When working on systems with dangerous media, PPE (personal protective equipment) must be adjusted in accordance with the risk assessment. Before opening flange connections, the residual risk due to trapped energy (spring force or static pressure) must be assessed.

3. Required diagnostic tools

4. Initial assessment checklist

5. Systematic diagnostic process

1. Symptom: Audible knock when pump stops.
   • Test: Analysis of the pressure curve using a DAQ system (pressure sensor near the valve).
   • IF pressure peak > 1.5 x system pressure:
     • Cause: Closing speed too high, valve closes too late.
     • Action: Increase spring force or check damping mechanism.
   • IF pressure peak < 1,2 x Systemdruck:
     • Cause: Mechanical play in the valve seat.
     • Action: Check valve internal parts for wear.
2. Symptom: Pipe vibrations.
   • Test: Measure vibration on valve body.
   • IF frequency correlates with valve movement:
     • Cause: Valve oscillates in the partial load range.
     • Action: Check valve nominal diameter (DN), verify flow velocity.

6. Error-cause matrix

7. Root cause analysis

A check valve ideally closes when the flow velocity is close to zero. However, if the valve only closes when the flow has already reversed, the abrupt stop results in a massive pressure spike. In the case of piston check valves, this can be caused by contamination of the damping bore or, in the case of flaps, by too inert mass. If left untreated, this will lead to material fatigue, flange loosening and premature pipe support failure.

8. Step-by-step repair

1. Apply LOTO: De-energize the system and release pressure.
2. Valve inspection: Open the cover, check the valve plate/cone for grooves or deposits.
3. Adjust damping: For spring-loaded valves, increase the spring force according to the manufacturer's specifications or check the wear of the damping bushings.
4. Damper installation: If quick closing is not possible for design reasons, install an external hydraulic damper.
5. Verification: System start-up, simulate pump stop under full load, validate pressure curve with DAQ.

9. Preventive measures

10. Spare parts and components

Order the spare parts you need directly in our e-catalog at: https://www.unitecd.com/e-catalog/

11. References

• DIN EN 12334: Industrial valves - non-return valves made of metal.
• DIN EN 60204-1: Safety of machines - Electrical equipment.
• VDI 2033: Noises in piping systems.