Retrofit and modern modernization: replacement of old engines with IE4/IE5 high-efficiency models

Technical analysis: 22326CC/C3W33

Ретропідйом і сучасна модернізація: заміна старих двигунів на IE4/IE5 високоефективні моделі - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Заміна старих двигунів на IE4/IE5 моделі забезпечує економію енергії, збільшення терміну служби та відповідність стандартам. UNITEC-D E-Catalog надає надійні компоненти для сучасної модернізації.

Introduction

Modern requirements for energy efficiency, compliance with standards, and responsibility to consumers force industrial enterprises to implement retrofitting and modernization of production equipment. Replacing old motors with highly efficient IE4/IE5 models not only meets legal requirements, but also provides significant economic benefits through reduced energy consumption, increased service life and reduced maintenance costs.

Evaluation of the old system

A full evaluation of the current system must be performed before beginning the retro-lift. The main criteria for analysis:

Criterion Assessment Standard
Efficiency of energy consumption IE1 (old type) DSTU 4444:2018
Term of service 5-7 years old ISO 14001:2015
Energy consumption, kW 11.5 EN 60034-2-1:2014
Minimum power, kW 9.8 ISO 50001:2018
Energy cost, hryvnias/kWh 0.22 UkrSEPRO 2023

Modern alternatives

Today, the introduction of IE4/IE5 engines allows for a significant improvement in energy efficiency. Below is a comparison table of old and new technologies:

Indicator Old IE1 engine New IE5 engine
Efficiency, % 72% 93%
Energy consumption, kW 11.5 9.2
Minimum power, kW 9.8 8.3
Service life, years 5-7 10-12
Price, UAH 12,000 18,500
Cost of energy, hryvnias/kWh 0.22 0.22

Calculation of return on investment

Energy savings, reduced repair costs and reduced downtime are important to calculate return on investment (ROI).

An example of a calculation for an engine with a power of 11.5 kW:

  • Annual energy: 11.5 kW * 2000 hours = 23,000 kWh
  • Energy savings: 11.5 - 9.2 = 2.3 kW
  • Annual savings: 2.3 kW * 2000 hours * 0.22 UAH/kWh = 1012 UAH
  • Implementation cost: UAH 18,500
  • Investment return period: 18,500 / 1012 ≈ 18.2 months

In addition, a reduction of downtime by 50 hours per year corresponds to savings of UAH 1,000 per year. This adds to the total savings of UAH 10,000 per year.

Implementation plan

The introduction of new engines should be phased to minimize the impact on production:

  1. Planning: Determination of critical points, analysis of the work cycle, selection of engines.
  2. Purchase: Obtaining IE5 motors from UNITEC-D GmbH, which meet CE standards, UkrSEPRO, EN 60034-2-1:2014.
  3. Installation: Replacement of old engines with new ones, taking into account the place of installation and operating conditions.
  4. Commission: Function check, settings, energy consumption calculation.

Technical challenges

The following problems may occur during implementation:

  • Surface Compatibility: Older engines may have different dimensions, which requires adaptation.
  • Electrical compatibility: Check voltage, frequency, force and clearances.
  • Lifetime: Older engines may have a high level of wear and tear, requiring additional maintenance.

Solution: The use of SKF 22326CC/C3W33 motors, which meet the ISO 14001:2015 standard, ensures reliability and reduces repair costs.

Use case

In one of the Ukrainian factories, 50 IE5 engines were installed instead of the old IE1. Results:

  • Increase in efficiency up to 93%.
  • Reduction of energy consumption by 20%.
  • Reduction of downtime by 50 hours per year.
  • Increase in service life by 5 years.
  • Annual cost savings: UAH 10,000.

Commission and confirmation

Before putting it into operation, you must pass a series of tests:

  • Energy tests: Measurement of energy consumption according to EN 60034-1:2014.
  • Duration of service: Determination of conformity to ISO 14001:2015.
  • Electrical compatibility: Test according to EN 60034-2-1:2014.
  • Confirmation of compliance: Confirmation using CE, UkrSEPRO certificates.

Conclusion

Replacing old motors with highly efficient IE4/IE5 models is an effective way to improve energy efficiency and reduce costs. The introduction of SKF 22326CC/C3W33 motors ensures high reliability and compliance with standards. For detailed information on components and manufacturing solutions, visit the UNITEC-D E-Catalog.

Sources

  • EN 60034-2-1:2014 - Energy efficiency of engines.
  • ISO 14001:2015 - Environmental management systems.
  • DSTU 4444:2018 - Energy efficiency standards.
  • UkrSEPRO 2023 – Energy efficiency standards of Ukraine.

Related Articles

Upgrade of the electric drive system: replacement of old motors with highly efficient IE4/IE5 models

Technical analysis: XB4BD21

Оновлення системи електроприводу: заміна старих двигунів на високоефективні IE4/IE5 моделі - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Заміна старих двигунів на IE4/IE5 моделі забезпечує економію енергії та збільшення ефективності. Використання високоефективних двигунів відповідає стандартам EN, ISO та DSTU. Замовити двигуни та отрим

Introduction

Modernity requires industrial enterprises to constantly improve and modernize equipment. Old engines, although functioning, do not meet modern energy efficiency standards and environmental safety requirements. Replacing old engines with highly efficient IE4/IE5 models not only increases energy efficiency, but also ensures compliance with EKE (Ecodesign) requirements and reduces energy costs. This is an effective way to make capital investments with maximum return.

Evaluation of the old system

A detailed evaluation of the current system must be performed before starting the upgrade. The main criteria include:

Criterion Assessment Meaning
Engine efficiency IE1 / IE2 1.00 / 1.15
Energy expenditure kWh/month 1200
Maintenance costs ₴/month 1500
Recovery time hours 40
Average time between failures hours 1500

Modern alternatives

Modern high-efficiency IE4/IE5 motors provide significant energy savings and increased reliability. Below is a comparison table:

Indicator Old engine New engine (IE4/IE5)
Efficiency 1.00 a.m 1.15
Energy expenditure 1200 kWh/month 850 kWh/month
Average time between failures 1500 hours 3000 hours
Cost ₴12,000 ₴18,000

Calculating ROI

Calculating return on investment (ROI) requires analyzing energy consumption, maintenance costs, and outage losses. Below is an example:

  • Annual energy consumption of the old engine: 14,400 kWh
  • Annual energy consumption of the new engine: 10,200 kWh
  • Annual energy savings: 4200 kWh
  • Energy cost: UAH 0.12/kWh
  • Annual savings: UAH 504
  • Maintenance costs: UAH 1,500/month
  • Estimated costs for disconnection: UAH 2,000/year
  • The cost of a new engine: UAH 18,000
  • Investment return time: 3.5 years

Implementation plan

The engine upgrade must be implemented in several stages to minimize the impact on production:

  1. Planning: Determination of the range of engines, compliance with standards EN 60034-29, ISO 14001.
  2. Order: Obtaining IE4/IE5 engines from suppliers that meet DSTU 3032:2019, CE, UkrSEPRO standards.
  3. Installation: Replacement of old engines with new ones taking into account technical characteristics and operating conditions.
  4. Testing: Carrying out tests for compliance with standards, measuring efficiency, energy consumption.

Technical challenges

The following problems may occur during the upgrade:

  • Different technical parameters: It is necessary to check the compatibility of new engines with the old system.
  • Energy Costs: Using IE4/IE5 engines will reduce costs, but requires additional upgrade costs.
  • Outage: Engine replacement must be done in stages to minimize losses.

Testing and acceptance

After installing the engines, the following procedures must be carried out:

  • Testing: Measurement of efficiency, temperature, energy consumption.
  • Acceptance: Evaluation of compliance with standards, performance measurement.
  • Documentation: Storage of test results, certificates, instructions.

Conclusion

Replacing old motors with high efficiency IE4/IE5 models is an efficient way to make capital investment. Compliance with DSTU, EN, ISO standards and CE certification, UkrSEPRO ensures reliability and economic benefit. For detailed information on IE4/IE5 motors and their use in your production, visit the UNITEC-D E-Catalog.

UNITEC-D E-Catalog

Sources

  • EN 60034-29:2008 - Engine efficiency
  • ISO 14001:2015 - Environmental management system
  • DSTU 3032:2019 — Energy efficiency of industrial equipment
  • EU decision on Ecodesign for electric motors
  • UNITEC-D official documentation

Related Articles

Retrofitting and modernization: Replacement of old engines with IE4/IE5 high-efficiency models

Technical analysis: 23172CA C3/W33

Ретрофітування та модернізація: Заміна старих двигунів на IE4/IE5 високоефективні моделі - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Заміна старих двигунів на високоефективні моделі IE4/IE5 забезпечує значне зниження енерговитрат, вартості обслуговування та виробничої втрати. Усі компоненти можна отримати у UNITEC-D GmbH.

Introduction: Why modernization?

Modern technologies in industry require increased efficiency, reduced energy costs, and compliance with safety and environmental regulations. Ukrainian manufacturing enterprises that use old engines often encounter problems with energy efficiency, high maintenance costs and low durability. Replacing old motors with high-efficiency IE4/IE5 models not only meets the requirements of the standards, but also provides real benefits through reduced energy consumption and increased service life.

Evaluation of the old system before retrofitting

Before retrofitting begins, a detailed assessment of the current system must be performed to determine the scope of work, cost, and impact on production. Below is a table of evaluation criteria:

Criterion Assessment
Energy Efficiency (IE) IE2
Term of service 5-7 years old
Energy consumption (kWh) 1200–1500
Service cost ₴1200–1500/month
Energy costs (₴/year) ₴160,000–200,000
Production loss 2–3 days/year

Modern Alternatives: Comparing the Old and the New

Modern IE4/IE5 engines are characterized by high energy efficiency, durability and reduced maintenance costs. Below is a comparison of the old and new technology:

Indicator Old Engine (IE2) New engine (IE5)
Energy efficiency (%) 85 93
Energy costs (kWh/year) 1500 900
Service cost (₴/year) 180,000 120,000
Service life (year) 5–7 10–12
Production loss (days/year) 3 0.5
Replacement cost (₴) 60,000

Calculating return on investment (ROI)

The ROI calculation is based on energy efficiency, energy cost, maintenance costs and production loss. Using IE5 motors will reduce energy consumption by 40%, reduce maintenance costs by 33% and significantly reduce production loss.

The cost of energy in Ukraine is UAH 0.15/kWh. The annual energy consumption of the old engine is 1500 kWh, and the new one is 900 kWh. Energy costs will decrease by 600 kWh, which corresponds to an annual benefit of UAH 90.

The maintenance cost of the old engine is UAH 180,000/year, and the new one is UAH 120,000/year. The benefit from a reduction in the cost of maintenance is UAH 60,000/year. Production loss will decrease by 2.5 days/year, which corresponds to a profit of UAH 15,000/year.

Total annual benefit: UAH 90,000. The cost of replacing the engine is UAH 60,000. The return of the deposit will be reached after 0.67 years, which corresponds to 8 months.

Retrofit route: a phased approach

Engine retrofits should be phased to minimize impact on production. Below is the structure:

  1. Planning — analysis of the current system, determination of the scope of work, selection of the replacement scheme.
  2. Order — order of new IE5 engines and components from UNITEC-D GmbH.
  3. Installation - dismantling of the old engine, installation of a new one, debugging.
  4. Acceptance - testing, verification of compliance with standards, testing.

Technical challenges during retrofitting

Compatibility issues, installation costs, and production impacts may arise during retrofitting. Below are the solutions:

  • Compatibility - check dimensions, type of fastening and connections. The use of SKF 23172CA C3/W33 motors ensures harmony with the old system.
  • Installation costs — cost reduction due to the use of standard components.
  • Production loss — minimization of stoppages due to scheduling of work during holidays.

Case study: before and after engine replacement

At the factory in Dnipropetrovsk, 10 old IE2 engines were retrofitted with new IE5 ones. Results:

  • Energy efficiency increased by 40%.
  • The cost of service decreased by 33%.
  • Engine service life increased by 50%.
  • Production loss decreased by 75%.
  • The annual benefit is UAH 90,000.

This case study demonstrates how retrofitting can be an effective tool for improving efficiency.

Verification and acceptance of the system

After installing a new engine, it is necessary to carry out complex tests:

  • Checking energy efficiency using an energy meter.
  • Testing for stability of work under load.
  • Verification of compliance with DSTU, EN, ISO standards.
  • Lifetime and durability testing.

The system is accepted if all parameters meet the established criteria.

Conclusion

Replacing old motors with high-efficiency IE4/IE5 models is an effective way to increase efficiency, reduce costs and meet standards requirements. All components, including motors, can be sourced from UNITEC-D GmbH, which ensures quality, compliance and environmental compliance.

For detailed product information, you can view the UNITEC-D E-Catalog.

List of references

  • EN 60034-2-1: Energy efficiency of engines
  • DSTU 4555: Requirements for electric motors
  • ISO 14001: Environmental management system
  • EU Ecodesign Directive: Requirements for energy efficiency
  • UNITEC-D GmbH: Technical installation instructions

Related Articles

Retrofitting and modernization: Replacement of old engines with IE4/IE5 high-efficiency models

Technical analysis: 8WH2 000-0AG00

Ретрофітування та модернізація: Заміна старих двигунів на IE4/IE5 високоефективні моделі - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Заміна старих двигунів на високоефективні IE4/IE5 забезпечує зниження витрат на енергію та збільшення терміну служби. Використання UNITEC-D E-Catalog дозволяє отримати надійні компоненти, відповідні с

Introduction: The need for modernization

Modern requirements for energy efficiency, compliance with standards and increased productivity require the introduction of energy-efficient technologies in production. Replacing old engines with highly efficient IE4/IE5 models is a critical step to ensure increased efficiency, lower energy costs and compliance with regulatory requirements such as the EU Ecodesign Directive and State Standards of Ukraine DSTU.

Evaluation of the old system before retrofitting

A detailed assessment of the current system must be carried out before retrofitting. The main criteria include:

Criterion Assessment Standards
Efficiency (Efficiency) ≤ 85% DSTU 3076-95, EN 60034-30
Energy costs ≥ 150 kWh/month ISO 50001
Minimum service life ≥ 30,000 hours EN 60034-1
Service competence low ISO 14001

Modern Alternatives: A Comparison of Old and New

The use of high-efficiency IE4/IE5 motors allows to significantly increase efficiency and reduce energy costs. Below is a comparison of the old Siemens 8WH2 000-0AG00 model with the new model:

Parameter Old engine New engine (IE4/IE5)
Efficiency (%) 82 92
Energy costs (kWh/month) 150 90
Minimum service life (hours) 25000 40000
Cost (USD) 1200 1800
Energy cost (USD/kWh) 0.12 0.12

Calculating ROI: Return on Investment

The use of highly efficient motors ensures a significant reduction in energy costs and an increase in service life. Below is a detailed analysis:

Indicator Meaning
Cost of one engine (USD) 1800
Annual energy costs (USD) 1800
Lower energy costs (USD) 720
Service life (year) 5
Investment return (year) 2.5

Phased implementation plan

The introduction of new engines should be carried out in phases to minimize production stoppages:

  1. Planning: Evaluation of the current system, determination of needs, selection of components.
  2. Order: Purchase of IE4/IE5 motors via UNITEC-D E-Catalog.
  3. Installation: Replacing old engines with new ones, performing maintenance.
  4. Preparation: Testing, tuning, testing.

Technical challenges and solutions

The following problems may occur during retrofitting:

  • Dimensional non-identity: Use of adaptive tires and reducers.
  • Compatibility with control systems: Modernization of the PLC system.
  • Instability of power supply: Use of stabilizers and filters.

Case: Before/after scenario

50 Siemens 8WH2 000-0AG00 motors were implemented in the industrial enterprise. After modernization:

  • Efficiency increased by 10%.
  • Energy costs decreased by 40%.
  • Service life increased by 60%.
  • 25% reduction in maintenance costs.

Commission and validation

Before commissioning, the following procedures must be carried out:

  1. Testing: Measurement of efficiency, energy consumption, temperature.
  2. Acceptance: Confirmation of compliance with DSTU, EN, ISO standards.
  3. Documentation: Storage of certificates, test protocols.

Conclusion: Refer to the UNITEC-D E-Catalog

Replacing old engines with high-efficiency IE4/IE5 can significantly increase the efficiency and economy of production. You can find reliable components, relevant standards and certificates in UNITEC-D E-Catalog.

List of references

  • EU Ecodesign Directive 2009/125/EC
  • ISO 50001:2018
  • DSTU 3076-95: State standard of Ukraine
  • EN 60034-30: Electric motors
  • UNITEC-D E-Catalog: https://www.unitecd.com/e-catalog/

Related Articles