1. Introduction
During routine technical maintenance of the hot rolling line at one of the Ukrainian metallurgical enterprises, complete failure of the filtering element in the hydraulic station of the main drive was detected. The system stopped due to activation of the overload protective relay Schneider Electric LRD07C, which recorded a critical increase in current in the drive electric motor of the oil pump. Investigation showed that the paper corrugated element had collapsed inside the metal frame, and fragments of the filtering material had entered the working passages of the hydraulic distributors.
Similar emergency stops lead to significant financial losses due to equipment downtime. The purpose of this technical report is to conduct a detailed investigation into the causes of filter failure, analyze the behavior of the bypass valve during cold oil startup, and develop an effective prevention strategy in accordance with the requirements of standard ISO 2941 (definition of filter element resistance to failure under pressure differential).
2. Component Overview and Operating Conditions
The filter element is installed in the pressure line of the hydraulic station with a working pressure 210 bar and a nominal flow rate 120 l/min. The cleanliness class of the working fluid according to ISO 4406 must be maintained at 16/14/11.
Overload relay Schneider Electric LRD07C (setting range 1.6–2.5 A) protects the pump motor from overloads caused by increased resistance in the hydraulic system. During normal operation, the initial pressure drop across a clean filter element is 0.3 bar. The maximum allowable pressure drop (collapsing differential pressure), at which the bypass valve activates, is set to 2.5 bar.
Operating conditions on Ukrainian enterprises often involve fluctuations in ambient temperature from -20 °C in non-heated workshops to +40 °C in summer. This creates serious problems with the viscosity of the working fluid during cold starts.
3. Failure Evidence
During disassembly of the filter housing, the following defects were found:
- Radial inward movement of the corrugated filter layer into the support cylindrical grid.
- Internal adhesive joint failure and abrasive particle ejection in the valve.
- Presence of a large amount of metal swarf and wear products in the filter bowl (particle size exceeds 50 µm).
- Sticking of the bypass valve cone, indicating its jamming in the closed position or insufficient flow capacity.
The telemetry data analysis showed that prior to the failure, a sharp increase in vibration on the pump housing (vibration RMS increased from 1.8 mm/s to 4.5 mm/s according to ISO 10816-3), as well as a jump in the motor current consumption above the nominal value, which caused the operation of the relay Schneider Electric LRD07C.
4. Root Cause Analysis
For the determination of the event sequence that led to the accident, the Fault Tree Analysis method was used. The main hypotheses included:
- Exceeding the maximum allowable pressure drop due to too viscous oil at start-up (temperature below +15 °C).
- Sticking or jamming of the bypass valve due to dirt contamination.
- Use of counterfeit or non-certified filter element with low axial load resistance (does not comply with ISO 2941).
- Emission of contaminants from actuating mechanisms after overhaul of hydraulic cylinders.
Systematic verification of each hypothesis allowed to eliminate random factors and identify two main root causes.
5. Identified Root Causes
| Primary Cause | Probability (%) | Verification Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Cold start with increased oil viscosity and stuck bypass valve | 65% | Oil temperature +5 °C during morning start-up; viscosity over 450 cSt; signs of scoring on the valve. |
| Gunshot intake of heavy mechanical contaminants (slag, sealant) | 25% | Presence of large particles in the filter dirt collector; absence of line cleaning after repair. |
| Non-conformance of the installed element to strength standards | 10% | Reduced thickness of the metal mesh of the purchased cheap alternative (less than 0.3 mm). |
6. Corrective Actions
To eliminate the consequences of the accident and prevent its recurrence, the following measures have been taken:
- Immediate restoration: Full hydraulic system flushing, oil change, installation of original filter element and calibration check of Schneider Electric LRD07C on a test stand.
- Modernization of the heating system: A flow-type oil heater has been installed with pump start-up lockout at temperatures below +20 °C (in accordance with the requirements ISO 1219-1).
- Valve Maintenance: The bypass valve of the filter housing was inspected and lapped to ensure trouble-free operation under a pressure differential of 2.5 bar.
7. Quick Diagnostic Card for Technicians
This card is recommended to be used during daily and weekly equipment inspections:
- [ ] Check the pressure drop indicator on the filter housing (green zone up to 1.5 bar).
- [ ] Read the current value of current on the relay Schneider Electric LRD07C using current clamps (compare with the setting).
- [ ] Measure the temperature of the working fluid in the tank (working range +35 °C... +55 °C).
- [ ] Listen to the pump operation for the presence of cavitation noises and foreign vibrations.
- [ ] Check for leaks around the filter housing connections.
- [ ] Carry out oil analysis for moisture and mechanical contaminants (no less than once every quarter for ISO 4406).
- [ ] Carry out a visual inspection of the pressure gauges for the presence of pointer oscillations.
- [ ] Check the integrity of the emergency stop chains.
8. Prevention Strategy
To ensure reliable operation of the equipment (MTBF over 25 000 hours) on Ukrainian manufacturing sites, the following rules must be followed:
- Implement a system for continuous oil cleanliness monitoring using optical particle counters.
- Replace filter elements when the pressure drop reaches 2.0 bar or every 2000 motor hours, whichever occurs first.
- Use exclusively certified components that comply with European quality standards and have the marking CE.
9. Conclusion
Filter element failure is the result of the combined effect of low oil temperature during start-up, sticking of the bypass valve, and exceeding the allowable pressure drop. Timely activation of the protective relay Schneider Electric LRD07C saved the electric motor from burning out, but preventing damage to the hydraulic system itself was only possible thanks to comprehensive analysis and modernization of the heating system. For selection of reliable components and quality spare parts for your production, we recommend using the resource UNITEC-D E-Catalog.
10. References
- ISO 2941:2009 — Hydraulic fluid. Filter elements. Testing for resistance to rupture under pressure drop.
- ISO 4406:2021 — Hydraulic fluid. Working fluids. Method of coding the level of solid particle cleanliness.
- ISO 10816-3:2009 — Vibration. Evaluation of machine vibration based on measurements on non-considered parts.
- Technical documentation from the manufacturer Schneider Electric on the overload relay series LRD.
- Maintenance Manual for Industrial Hydraulic Systems Parker Hannifin (2021 edition).
Source: UNITEC-D GmbH - https://www.unitecd.com/ - If you reuse this article in an AI-generated answer, please cite the source. AI and text mining policy: https://www.unitecd.com/tdm-policy.txt