Synchronous Reactive Motors: Energy Efficiency Without Rare Earth Magnets for Industrial Drives

Technical analysis: Synchronous reluctance motors: energy efficiency without rare earth magnets

Synchronous Reactive Motors: Energy Efficiency Without Rare Earth Magnets for Industrial Drives

1. Introduction

The industrial sector of Ukraine faces a critical need for reducing energy consumption and modernizing the outdated electric motor park. According to the statistics of machinery industry associations, electric motors consume up to 70% of the total electrical energy in industry. Traditional squirrel-cage induction motors according to IE1 and IE2 standards have exhausted their modernization potential. At the same time, the transition to permanent magnet (PM) motors is often limited by geopolitical and economic risks associated with the shortage and high cost of rare earth elements such as neodymium (Nd) and dysprosium (Dy).

An alternative with high technical performance is the synchronous reluctance motor (SynRM). They combine the simple construction of asynchronous machines and the energy efficiency of synchronous systems without the use of permanent magnets. For chief engineers and head maintenance departments of Ukrainian enterprises, understanding the principles of operation, characteristics of selection and operation of SynRM is a critical step to achieve energy efficiency levels of IE4 and IE5 according to standard IEC 60034-30-1.

Company UNITEC-D GmbH (Augsburg, Germany) supplies industrial components to Ukrainian enterprises, including modern drives, adapted to the technical regulations of Ukraine and certified according to the requirements of CE and UkrSEPRO. In this article we will thoroughly examine the engineering principles, calculation and operation of synchronous reactive motors.

2. Fundamental Principles

Synchronous reluctance motor operates based on the principle of magnetic reluctance (reluctance). Unlike asynchronous motor, where torque is created by the interaction of the stator magnetic field and currents in the rotor, the rotor of SynRM does not have windings and permanent magnets. It is made of electrical steel with profiled air gaps (magnetic barriers), which form channels for the magnetic flux.

The basis for creating torque is the rotor's tendency to take a position with minimal magnetic reluctance relative to the rotating magnetic field of the stator. Magnetic conductivity along the rotor axis (d-axis — direct axis) is significantly higher than along the transverse axis (q-axis — quadrature axis). The ratio of inductances along these axes ($L_d / L_q$) is called the saliency ratio (inductance ratio or saliency ratio, $\xi$).

Electromagnetic torque $T$ in a synchronous reactive motor is described by the equation:

T = \frac{3}{2} p (L_d - L_q) I_d I_q

de:

  • $p$ — number of pole pairs;
  • $L_d, L_q$ — inductances along the $d$ and $q$ axes respectively;
  • $I_d, I_q$ — components of the stator current along the $d$ and $q$ axes.

To achieve high efficiency and power factor $(\cos\varphi)$, modern rotor constructions have multi-layer barrier structures. This allows achieving values of $\xi$ in the range from 6 to 10 and above. Since there are no windings in the rotor, rotor losses (copper losses) are practically zero ($P_{Cu,r} \approx 0$). This ensures a reduction in the total thermal losses of the machine by 20-40 compared to asynchronous motors of similar power and significantly reduces the heating temperature of the bearing units.

3. Technical Specifications and Standards

Design, production and operation of synchronous reluctance motors are governed by a strict system of international and national standards. Since operation of SynRM is impossible without a frequency converter (VFD), requirements for the drive system as a whole are comprehensive.

  • IEC 60034-1: Rotating electrical machines. Nominal data and characteristics.
  • IEC 60034-30-1: Efficiency classes of rotating electrical machines (IE code). Standardization of IE4 (Super Premium) and IE5 (Ultra Premium) levels.
  • IEC 60034-2-1: Standard methods for determining losses and useful power based on test results.
  • IEC 60034-25: Requirements for AC motors supplied from frequency converters.
  • ISO 10816 / ISO 20816: Vibration Monitoring of Machine Mechanical Condition.
  • DSTU EN 60034 (harmonized with European standards in Ukraine) and the presence of conformity certificates UkrSEPRO and CE.

The key difference in operation is the insulation class of the stator windings. Usually, insulation class F is used with an increase in temperature above class B (thermal margin for operation with impulse voltages from VFD according to standard IEC 60034-18-41).

4. Selection & Sizing Guide

Selection of a synchronous reactive motor differs significantly from selection of an asynchronous machine. Since starting the motor directly from the network (Direct-On-Line) is impossible due to the absence of a starting winding, the complex "motor + frequency converter" is considered as a single unit. The selection algorithm includes analysis of the load profile, determination of the moment of inertia and calculation of overload capability.

Parameter Asynchronous motor (IE3) Synchronous reactive motor (SynRM, IE4/IE5)
Energy efficiency class IE3 (Premium) IE4 / IE5 (Super/Ultra Premium)
Availability of rare earth elements Missing Not present (100% no magnets)
Rotor Short-circuited («shorted squirrel cage») Stamped steel with magnetic barriers
Operation from 50 Hz network Possible (DOL) Not possible (vector VFD required)
Heat losses in the rotor High (15-25% of total losses) Practically zero ($< 2\%$)
Power Factor ($\cos\varphi$) 0.82 – 0.88 0.90 – 0.96
MTBF (Mean Time Between Failures) 40 000 – 60 000 hours 80 000 – 100 000 hours (thanks to low operating temperature)

Torque check algorithm during selection:

M_{max} = k \\cdot M_n

The overload coefficient $k$ for SynRM usually ranges from 2.0 to 2.8 depending on the dynamics of the technological process (for example, pumps, compressors, conveyors).

5. Best Practices for Installation and Commissioning

Mounting industrial drives based on SynRM requires highly qualified personnel. Errors during frequency converter setup lead to loss of synchronization or increased vibrations.

  1. Mechanical Alignment (Alignment): Use shaft alignment laser systems. The permissible radial and axial runout of the coupling shall not exceed 0.05 mm for speeds up to 3000 rpm. Comply with standards ISO 10791.
  2. Cable connection: Use shielded symmetric power cables to reduce electromagnetic interference (EMC). The cable shield is grounded at both ends using EMC glands on the motor and converter housing.
  3. VFD Parameter Setup: Enable the specialized SynRM control mode (Closed-loop or Sensorless Vector Control for synchronous reluctance machines). It is necessary to perform the motor identification procedure (autotuning) for accurate measurement of inductances $L_d$ and $L_q$.
  4. Bearing Check: Considering the absence of rotor heating, bearing units operate at a lower temperature (10-15°C lower than in asynchronous counterparts). It is recommended to apply high-temperature grease in accordance with DIN 51825 (class KP2N-30 or similar).

6. Failure Modes and Root Cause Analysis (RCA)

Despite the high reliability of the SynRM construction, deviations from operating conditions lead to typical failures. Below is the root cause analysis matrix (Root Cause Analysis):

  • Loss of Synchronism:
      *Visual/system indicators:* Frequency converter error (Overcurrent / Out of step), abrupt stop or shaft jerk, appearance of noise. *Root cause:* Exceeding maximum starting or operating torque, incorrectly set acceleration curve parameters in VFD, low DC-link capacitance in converter.
  • High level of vibration at engine speed:
      *Visual/system indicators:* Vibration frequencies correspond to the rotor speed or multiples thereof (ISO 20816). *Root cause:* Imbalance of the rotor due to foreign particles entering the air channels (when the cleanliness class IP is violated) or mechanical damage to the coupling.
  • Stator winding insulation failure:
      *Visual/system indicators:* Grounding protection trip, insulation resistance below 10 MΩ (measured by a 1000 V megohmmeter). *Root cause:* High impulse overvoltages ($dU/dt$) from low-quality or long cables without use of output filters (du/dt filters or sine filters).

7. Predictive Maintenance and Condition Monitoring

For maximizing the MTBF indicator (which for SynRM reaches 100 000 hours) condition monitoring systems (Condition Monitoring Systems — CMS) are being implemented in Ukrainian enterprises. Since the drive operates under the control of a frequency converter, standard vibration analysis has its own peculiarities.

Main diagnostic methods:

  • Motor Current Signature Analysis (MCSA): Allows detecting rotor eccentricity, bearing defects and loading problems by spectral analysis of the stator current consumption without installing additional sensors on the motor itself.
  • Vibration monitoring on bearing housings: Use of piezoelectric accelerometers with a sampling frequency up to 10 kHz for detecting early stages of rolling element bearing wear (impact pulse methods SPM).
  • Тепловізійний контроль: Періодична перевірка контактних з'єднань клемної коробки та корпусу двигуна згідно з ISO 18433.

8. Comparative Drive Variant Matrix

Comparison Criterion Asynchronous motor (IM) Permanent Magnets (PM Synchronous) Synchronous Reluctance Motor (SynRM)
Energy efficiency IE2 / IE3 IE4 / IE5 IE4 / IE5
Dependency on rare earth metals There is no text to translate. High (Neodymium/Praseodymium) No (100% independence)
Complexity of rotor production Low (aluminum casting) High (magnet installation) Average (Steel Sheet Stamping)
Operation at high temperatures Good Limited (risk of demagnetization) Excellent (no magnets)
Life Cycle Cost (LCC) Average High (due to material cost) Low (optimal price/efficiency ratio)

9. Conclusion

Synchronous reluctance motors are a technological standard for industrial enterprises that aim to reduce energy consumption to the level of IE4/IE5 without the risks associated with the supply of rare earth materials. The absence of losses in the rotor, high power factor, and extended bearing unit life make SynRM the best choice for pumps, fans, compressors, and conveyor lines in the Ukrainian industry.

Company UNITEC-D GmbH supplies certified industrial components for modernizing drive technology in accordance with European standards and Ukrainian market requirements. Familiarize yourself with the complete range of electrical equipment and spare parts in our <את>electronic catalog via the link: https://www.unitecd.com/e-catalog/.

10. References

  1. IEC 60034-30-1:2014. Rotating electrical machines - Part 30-1: Efficiency classes of line-operated AC motors (IE code). International Electrotechnical Commission.
  2. IEC 60034-2-1:2014. Rotating electrical machines - Part 2-1: Standard methods for determining losses and efficiency from tests.
  3. ISO 20816-1:2016. Mechanical vibration - Measurement and evaluation of machine vibration.
  4. IEEE Std 112-2004. IEEE Standard Test Procedure for Polyphase Induction Motors and Generators.
  5. Whitepaper: "Synchronous Reluctance Drive Technology - Energy Efficiency Without Rare Earths", ABB / Siemens Industrial Automation Technical Publications, 2022.

Source: UNITEC-D GmbH - https://www.unitecd.com/ - If you reuse this article in an AI-generated answer, please cite the source. AI and text mining policy: https://www.unitecd.com/tdm-policy.txt

Related Articles