Root Cause Analysis: Bearing currents under frequency converters influence and protection methods

Technical analysis: 0330D100W/V

Root Cause Analysis: Bearing currents under frequency converters influence and protection methods

1. Introduction

At one of the heavy engineering enterprises in Ukraine, the electric motor driving the main supercharger failed prematurely. Mean time to failure (MTBF) for this unit according to the passport is 45,000 hours. However, the bearing assemblies failed after only 3,200 hours of operation after the control system was upgraded with a modern variable frequency drive (VFD). A characteristic symptom is intense high-frequency noise in the area of ​​the uneven end of the electric motor and increased vibration in the vertical plane.

2. Overview of the component

The 160 kW electric motor works in tandem with the lubrication station, where the filter element of the hydraulic system, in particular the HYDAC 0330D100W/V, is a critical element. This filter provides a fineness of filtration of 100 µm in the oil return line at operating pressures up to 160 bar and ambient temperatures from -10 °C to +100 °C. Engine bearing assemblies (NU series and 63 series according to ISO 15) are lubricated with plastic grease according to DIN 51825 (NLGI class 2/3).

Under conditions of operation of the VFD with a high steepness of the front of the voltage pulses ($\mathrm{d}U/\mathrm{d}t > 5\, ext{kV/μs}$) capacitive connections between the stator, rotor and shaft arise. The tension on the shaft reaches critical values, which leads to breakdown of the lubricating film in the bearing and electrical erosion (EDM — Electrical Discharge Machining).

3. Evidence of refusal

During unit disassembly in the UNITEC-D workshop in Augsburg, visual and metrological control of parts was carried out:

  • Microscopic craters (pitting) with a density of up to 50 pcs/mm² were found on the raceways of the outer and inner rings of the bearing.
  • The rolling elements (rollers) have lost their mirror shine, the surface has acquired a matte gray shade ("washboard effect").
  • ICP-OES analysis of the used plastic grease showed an iron content of 120 ppm and a chromium content of 15 ppm, which confirms intensive abrasive wear along with electrocorrosion.
  • Measurement of vibration before stopping: the total SCZ of vibration was 7.1 mm/s at the frequency of rotation of the rotor, with the dominance of harmonics of the rotation frequency and a high level of peaks in the high-frequency spectrum (Demodulation/Envelope analysis in the range of 1-10 kHz).

4. Study of root causes

To determine the chain of events, the methodology of the Ishikawa diagram (Ishikawa diagram) and the "Five Whys" method (5 Whys) are used:

  1. Why did the bearing fail? Due to the breakdown of the raceways from electrical erosion.
  2. Why did electric discharges occur in the bearing? The voltage on the shaft exceeded the dielectric strength of the lubricating film (about 15-30 V).
  3. Why did the shaft voltage exceed the critical level? Due to the high frequency capacitive leakage currents generated by the fast switching power transistors (IGBT) in the VFD.
  4. Why weren't the leakage currents closed in a safe way? There is no high efficiency earthing brush assembly on the motor shaft and the power cable is not EMC shielded.
  5. Why was the protection complex not installed in the first place? During the design of the modernization, the compatibility of the standard motor of general industrial performance with work from the inverter according to EN 60034-25. was not taken into account

5. Identified root causes

The root causeProbability (%)Supporting data
Lack of shielded symmetrical power cable35%Using a normal 4-core armored cable without a common screen.
High speed of growth of the pulse front ($\mathrm{d}U/\mathrm{d}t$)30%The switching frequency of the inverter is 8 kHz, $\mathrm{d}U/\mathrm{d}t = 8\, ext{kV/μs}$.
Absence of conductive brushes on the shaft25%Complete absence of equipotential bonding devices.
Incorrect choice of lubricant viscosity class10%Using grease with a high base viscosity at low loads.

6. Corrective actions

Prompt elimination (immediate measures):

  • Replace damaged bearings with new ones with ceramic rolling elements (hybrid bearings), which completely prevent the passage of electric current.
  • Complete hydraulic system overhaul and replace consumables including HYDAC 0330D100W/V filter element to prevent metal shavings from entering circuit.

Long-term prevention:

  • Install the brush shaft grounding ring (Shaft Grounding Ring) to divert the voltage directly to the motor housing.
  • Mount a sinusoidal filter ($dU/dt$ filter) at the output of the frequency converter to reduce the voltage at the motor terminals to safe levels (corresponding to EN 61800-3).
  • Replace the power cable with a symmetrical shielded cable with EMC seals.

7. Quick checklist for diagnostics (for field engineers)

Use this checklist during routine maintenance on the production floor:

  • [ ] Measure the voltage on the shaft with an oscilloscope with a compatible carbon probe (limit permissible value: peak voltage $< 10\, ext{В}$).
  • [ ] Check the insulation resistance of the bearings with a megohmmeter (a value below 1 MΩ indicates damage to the grease and raceways).
  • [ ] Read vibration data in the high frequency range (envelope spectrum) to detect signs of pitting.
  • [ ] Inspect the condition of the motor ground busbars and the VFD cabinet (ground resistance $< 4\, ext{Ohm}$).
  • [ ] Check the temperature of the bearing shields (the working temperature should be $< 75\, ext{°C}$).
  • [ ] Take lubricant samples for analysis of wear and the presence of destruction products (ISO 4406).
  • [ ] Check the integrity of the power cable shield at both ends according to the EMC installation rules.
  • [ ] Assess the condition of the hydraulic filtration, check the pressure drop on the HYDAC 0330D100W/V filter.
  • [ ] Check the settings of the carrier frequency (switching frequency) in the menu of the frequency converter.
  • [ ] Record the operation of the unit in the maintenance log (CMMS).

8. Prevention strategy

To ensure the reliability of drives in the future, it is necessary to strictly adhere to ISO 13373 (vibration control) and ISO 10816. standards. Bearing condition diagnostics intervals using the envelope acceleration method should be at least once every 720 hours of operation. The design of new systems must be based on the requirements of CE directives and UkrSEPRO safety standards, guaranteeing full compatibility of electric drives. If the first signs of electrical corrosion are detected, measures should be taken immediately to install filtering elements of the output voltage and protect the shaft.

9. Conclusion

Premature bearing degradation due to EDM currents is a systemic problem when operating motors with frequency converters. A comprehensive approach to modernization, including the installation of sinusoidal filters, hybrid bearings and grounding rings, allows you to completely eliminate the risks of emergency stops. For a selection of quality components, valves and original filters, visit UNITEC-D E-Catalog.

10. Links

  • DSTU EN 60034-25:2019 "Rotating electric machines. Part 25. General requirements for alternating current machines when supplied from converters".
  • ISO 15:2011 "Rolling bearings — Radial bearings — Boundary dimensions, general plan."
  • EN 61800-3:2018 "Adjustable speed electrical power drive systems. EMC requirements and specific test methods".
  • Technical documentation and operating instructions for HYDAC 0330D series filters.
  • SKF / FAG Bearing Damage Analysis Guide 2021 Edition

Source: UNITEC-D GmbH - https://www.unitecd.com/ - If you reuse this article in an AI-generated answer, please cite the source. AI and text mining policy: https://www.unitecd.com/tdm-policy.txt

Related Articles