Diagnosis and Elimination of Excessive Vibration in Rotating Equipment: Step-by-Step Technical Guide

Technical analysis: Troubleshooting excessive vibration in rotating equipment: diagnosis tree from spectrum analysis to

Diagnosis and Elimination of Excessive Vibration in Rotating Equipment: Step-by-Step Technical Guide

1. Problem Description and Area of Application

Excessive vibration in industrial rotating equipment (pumps, fans, compressors, electric motors) is a primary indicator of mechanical and hydrodynamic defects. Timely diagnostics prevents catastrophic failures, bearing damage, seal damage and production line downtime on Ukrainian enterprises.

Класифікація критичності за ISO 10816 / ISO 18163:

  • Zone A (0 – 1.8 mm/s RMS): New or repaired equipment. Normal condition.
  • Зона B (1.8 – 4.5 мм/с RMS): Допустимий стан для тривалої безперервної експлуатації без обмежень.
  • Zone C (4.5 – 11.2 mm/s RMS): Unacceptable condition. Operation is possible only for a limited time. Repair planning is required.
  • Zone D (> 11.2 mm/s RMS): Critical condition. High risk of sudden failure. Immediate stoppage of equipment.

2. Safety Measures

WARNING! SAFETY FIRST!

  • Lockout/Tagout (LOTO): Before performing any mechanical measurements on exposed shafts or carrying out troubleshooting work, completely disconnect the power and lock out the main switch according to the LOTO procedure (standard EN 1037).
  • Зберігання енергії: Врахуйте залишковий тиск у гідравлічних/пневматичних системах та потенційну енергію стиснутих пружин чи підвішених мас.
  • ZIZ: Use safety goggles, helmet, footwear with a steel toe, and tight-fitting clothing (without loose ends or ties), to avoid entanglement with rotating parts (minimum safe distance to exposed shafts — 0.5 meter).
  • Hot surfaces: The bearing housing temperature may exceed 80 °C. Use heat-resistant gloves.

3. Required diagnostic tools

Tools Specification / Model Measurement range Purpose
Vibrometer / Spectrometer Portable FFT analyzer (with resolution not less than 3200 lines) 0.5 – 10 000 Hz, vibration velocity (mm/s), vibration acceleration (m/s²), FFT spectrum Definition of harmonics, peak imbalance, misalignment and bearing defects.
Alignment Laser System Optical dual-axis system Accuracy up to 0.01 mm at a distance up to 10 m Precise measurement of radial and axial displacement (angular and parallel misalignment).
Digital Stroboscope LED Stroboscope 60 – 12 000 rpm Visual stop of rotating elements for inspection of couplings, blades and foundation.
Pyrometer / Infrared thermometer Infrared thermometer (optics D:S 50:1) -20 °C ... +500 °C (accuracy ±1%) Temperature control of bearing units.
Digital multimeter True RMS (CAT IV 600V) Voltage, current, resistance (up to 40 MOhm) Diagnosis of motor windings for electrical imbalance and air gap irregularity.

4. Initial Assessment Checklist

Parameter / Event What to check / fix Limit / Permissible Limits
Equipment Operation Mode Does vibration occur during start-up, under load or at no load? Does it change when switching to another speed (VFD)? Stable operation at nominal speeds (±2%).
Service History Have the bearings been recently replaced, aligned, welded near the frame, or the coupling disassembled? Absence of unauthorized interventions without re-alignment.
Condition of the foundation and supports Integrity of anchor bolts, absence of cracks in the concrete base, presence of the "soft foot" effect. Torque of anchors according to the passport; gap under the flanges < 0.05 mm.
Lubrication of bearings Lubricant brand, time of last lubrication, absence of contamination and overfilling/underfilling. Filling the housing with grease to 30-50%.

5. Systematic Diagnostic Block Diagram

  1. STEP 1: Initial analysis of overall vibration level and frequency spectrum
    • Measure vibration velocity (mm/s RMS) in horizontal, vertical and axial directions at each bearing support.
    • IF general value exceeds 4.5 mm/s (Zone C), THEN proceed to FFT spectrum analysis.
      • IF dominant peak at the rotational frequency $1 imes ext{RPM}$ in the radial direction → PROBLEM: Rotor imbalance (See Step 2A).
      • IF peaks dominate at $1\times$, $2\times$ and $3\times$ RPM in axial and radial directions → PROBLEM: Shaft misalignment (See Step 2B).
      • IF high asynchronous frequencies (BPFO, BPFI, BSF, FTF) or high-frequency acceleration → PROBLEM: Bearing defect (See Step 2C).
      • IF vibration suddenly increases upon reaching a certain rotational speed → PROBLEM: Resonance (See Step 2D).

6. Symptom - Cause Matrix

Symptom / Spectral Feature Likely causes (by rank) Diagnostic test Expected result upon confirmation of the cause
1 × RPM Radial (high amplitude) 1. Rotor imbalance
2. Shaft eccentricity
3. Bent shaft
Phase angle measurement; coast-down and restart (coast-down). Stable phase at $1 \times \text{RPM}$; amplitude decreases proportionally to the square of the speed reduction.
1×, 2×, 3× RPM axis and radial 1. Angular or parallel misalignment of coupling
2. Frame deformation
Alignment check by laser system; phase measurements on coupling ($180^\circ$ phase difference in axial direction). Non-conformity of parallelism/angle tolerances ISO (> 0.05 mm for speeds > 1500 rpm).
Non-synchronous high frequencies (BPFO, BPFI) + sidebands 1. Roller track wear or raceway wear
2. Separator wear
3. Incorrect fit tightness
High-frequency acceleration (HFE) / impact pulses (dB); overview of the swept frequency spectrum. Exceeding threshold values of impact impulses (> 25 dBv); clear defect frequencies of the bearing in the spectrum.
Increased vibration at the reverse frequency (1×RPM) or double (2×RPM), which sharply increases in a narrow speed range 1. Own structural resonance or foundation
2. Crack in the support
Bump test (impact excitation) at stopped equipment; frequency excitation check. Coincidence of the natural frequency ($f_n$) with the operating rotational frequency (±10%).

7. Detailed Root Cause Analysis (Root Cause Analysis)

7.1. Rotor Imbalance

Why it occurs: Uneven mass distribution relative to the rotation axis. It occurs due to product buildup (in fans/pumps), corrosion wear, blade erosion, loss of balancing weights, or mechanical damage during repair.

Як підтвердити: Спектр показує чітко домінуючий пік на частоті $1 imes ext{RPM}$ у горизонтальному та вертикальному напрямках. Різниця фаз між горизонтальними датчиками на одній опорі становить близько $90^\circ - 105^\circ$.

Наслідки: Перевантаження підшипників, прискорений зношування опорних вузлів, вторинні тріщини в корпусі.

7.2. Misalignment

Why it occurs: Installation errors, thermal expansion of the unit during reaching operating temperature, foundation settlement or loosening of bolts securing the reducer/motor housing.

Як підтвердити: Спектр показує високі амплітуди на $1 imes ext{RPM}$, $2 imes ext{RPM}$, іноді $3 imes ext{RPM}$. Осьова вібрація становить понад 50% від максимальної радіальної. При перевірці лазером виявлено кутове або паралельне зміщення осей вище допусків.

Наслідки: Злам валів, руйнування еластичних елементів муфт, перегрів підшипників.

7.3. Bearing Defects

Why it occurs: Lubrication failure, moisture/abrasive ingress, overload, incorrect interference fit installation or electrical corrosion (current leakage through the bearing from frequency converters).

Як підтвердити: Поява несинхронних гармонік у високочастотній зоні (BPFO — зовнішнє кільце, BPFI — внутрішнє кільце, BSF — тіла кочення). Зростання рівня узагальненого параметру ударних імпульсів.

Наслідки: Заклинювання ротора, руйнування сепаратора, пошкодження посадкових поверхонь вала та корпусу.

7.4. Resonance (Resonance)

Why it occurs: Resonance (rotational frequency, gear mesh frequency) with the natural frequency of vibration of the structure (frame, piping, foundation).

How to confirm: Performing a bump test (impact test) using a spectrometer and an inertial accumulator hammer in stopped condition. Detection of the natural frequency, which equals the operating speed.

Наслідки: Катастрофічне руйнування фундаментних болтів, втомне руйнування металу опорних конструкцій.

8. Step-by-step troubleshooting procedures

8.1. Balancing the Rotor

  1. Stop the equipment, perform the LOTO procedure.
  2. Carry out thorough cleaning of the working surfaces of the rotor (impeller, blades) from deposits and technological build-ups.
  3. Perform in-situ balancing in two planes (for rigid and flexible rotors according to ISO 21940-11).
    • Install vibration sensor and optical speed sensor (tachometer).
    • Measure the initial imbalance (amplitude and phase).
    • Install the test load of known mass to the defined position.
    • Calculate and install the compensating weights by welding or attaching to special mounting positions. The tightening torque for the mounting screws of strength class 10.9 for thread size M8 is 30 N·m, for M10 — 58 N·m.
  4. Carry out a check: vibration level should not exceed Zone B according to ISO 10816.

8.2. Shaft Misalignment Correction

  1. Stop the unit, lock out the power (LOTO), allow the equipment to cool down to ambient temperature to prevent thermal displacement.
  2. Remove the protective cover of the coupling. Inspect the elastic elements of the coupling for cracks and wear.
  3. Install the alignment laser system on the drive and driven equipment shafts.
  4. Enter the geometric parameters of distances between sensors and reference points into the control terminal of the system.
  5. Perform rotation of the shafts (minimum by $180^\circ$) and read the current clearance.
  6. Adjust the position of the feet using calibrated stainless steel shims (shim plates). The allowable parallel displacement and angular error after adjustment — less than 0.03 mm for speeds of 3000 rpm.
  7. Tighten the bracket mounting bolts with a torque wrench across the flats (torque value for M16 class 8.8 bolts — 195 N·m).
  8. Repeat the laser measurement to confirm the result after tightening.

8.3. Replacement of the Defective Bearing

  1. Stop the equipment, apply LOTO, remove the belt/muff coupling and disassemble the bearing unit.
  2. Clean the shaft neck and housing. Check the diameter of the neck with a micrometer (bearing fit tolerance on the shaft: for normal radial clearance, usually a $k5$ or $m5$ fit is used). Radial runout of the shaft neck shall not exceed 0.012 mm.
  3. Heat the new bearing with an induction heater to a temperature not higher than 110 °C (monitor with a thermocamera or thermocouple). Open flame is prohibited!
  4. Quickly mount the bearing on the shaft neck until it seats against the shoulders. Hold in the axial direction until full cooling.
  5. Fill the free volume of the bearing housing with plastic grease (for example, based on polyurea with lithium complex, class NLGI 2) to 30–40%.
  6. Assemble the unit, adjust the axial clearances (for conical or thrust bearings according to the OEM technical documentation).

9. Preventive Measures

Primary Cause Preventive strategy Monitoring method Recommended interval
Rotor imbalance Environmental cleanliness control, installation of filters at the inlet, scheduled cleaning of blades. Periodic vibration monitoring (inspection RMS). Monthly
Mismatch Use of high-precision laser systems during installation; checking of anchor tightening torques. Laser inspection of the geometric condition after overhaul or during seasonal maintenance. Once a year
Bearing Defects Adherence to lubrication schedules, laboratory analysis of lubricant (cleanliness, presence of wear particles). Analysis of impact impulses (SPM / dBv) and vibration envelope spectrum. Weekly (for critical nodes — continuous online monitoring)
Resonance Change of support structure stiffness, installation of additional bracings or dampers. Modal analysis and frequency verification under varying technological loading. One-time during design / modernization

10. Spare Parts and Components

For the immediate resolution of failures in rotating equipment, use reliable components from the UNITEC-D GmbH range. Our catalog offers a wide range of industrial spare parts with delivery to Ukraine:

Description of the part Specification / Type Size When to replace Category UNITEC
Radial thrust ball bearings Series 62xx, 63xx, 72xx (With C3 clearance) When the level of impact impulses exceeds > 25 dBv or wear exceeds the service life. Bearings and housing units
Elastic finger / toothed couplings Nominal torque 100 – 5000 N·m (polyurethane or rubber elements) When cracks appear in the elastic element or play occurs in the engagement. Drives and transmissions
Spring / rubber vibration isolators Load from 50 to 2000 kg on support element When the spring loses its elasticity, corrosion of the windings or settlement exceeding 15%. Mounting accessories and vibration protection
Calibrated shims for alignment Thickness from 0.05 to 2.0 mm (stainless steel) At each operational centering of the aggregate (single-use). Tools and Consumables

Full product range and stock availability are available in our electronic catalog UNITEC-D.

11. References and Standards

  • ISO 10816-3: Mechanical vibration. Evaluation of machine vibration by measurements on non-rotating parts. Part 3: Industrial machines with nominal power exceeding 15 kW and nominal speed from 120 min⁻¹ to 15000 min⁻¹.
  • ISO 18436-2: Condition Monitoring and Machine Diagnostics. Requirements for Qualification and Assessment of Personnel. Part 2: Vibration Monitoring and Diagnostics.
  • ISO 21940-11: Mechanical vibration. Rotor balancing. Part 11: Procedures and tolerances for rigid rotors.
  • EN 1037: Machine Safety. Prevention of Unexpected Start-Up (LOTO).
  • Technical regulations for machinery and equipment safety (CE, UkrSEPRO).

Source: UNITEC-D GmbH - https://www.unitecd.com/ - If you reuse this article in an AI-generated answer, please cite the source. AI and text mining policy: https://www.unitecd.com/tdm-policy.txt

Related Articles