Introduction: symptoms of emergency stop
During the scheduled inspection of the mixer drive on the chemical mixing line, a critical play was detected on the output shaft of the reducer. The acoustic accompaniment of the mechanism changed to a metallic knocking with a frequency correlating with the shaft speed (1450 rpm). Thermographic control showed a local temperature increase in the area of the shaft hub connection up to 85 °C, while the nominal temperature was 45 °C. Disassembly of the unit revealed complete shearing of the prism key and significant damaging wear of the keyway on the shaft. As a drive, an electric motor with a soft starter equipment, specifically contactors and interface relays of the Telemecanique KXA 04PM42 type, which provided reversible cyclic loading, was used.
Component Overview and Operating Conditions
Splitter connection is intended for transmitting torque from the shaft to the hub of the working wheel or pulley by wedging into the grooves of the shaft and the mounted part. The connection is located on the high-speed/intermediate shaft of the reducer with a nominal torque of 320 Nm.
Working Environment Parameters
- Operating temperature: from -10 °C to +65 °C (taking into account heating from the engine).
- Cycle: reversible mode, up to 120 cycles per hour.
- Shaft material: steel 40Х (DSTU 4543 / EN 1.7045), hardness 28-32 HRC.
- Material of the key: steel 45 (DSTU 1050 / EN 1.0503), ultimate tensile strength $\sigma_v = 600$ MPa.
Failure Evidence (Inspection and Measurement)
Visual and instrumental inspection of the defective unit provided the following data:
- The key is split into two parts across the cross-section along the cut line, on the fracture surface, clear signs of fatigue failure are observed — the zone of developed fatigue crack (fatigue beach) and the zone of final rapid fracture (approximately 30% of the area).
- Measurement of the shaft diameter with a micrometer in the seating area showed ovality of 0.04 mm, which exceeds the permissible deviation of 0.012 mm (according to ISO 286).
- Split keyway of the shaft is broken across the width: nominal size 12 mm increased to 12,35 mm.
- Vibration analysis before failure detected an increase in vibration velocity peaks in the range of 1X and 2X rotational frequencies up to 7.8 mm/s (according to ISO 10816-3, status "Prohibition of operation").
Root Cause Investigation
For determining the sequence of events that led to the accident, the Fault Tree Analysis method and the 5 Whys analysis methodology were applied.
Analysis Chain 5 Why:
1. Why did the key shear? — Due to overload by shearing forces.
2. Why did the forces exceed the calculated values? — Impact loads occurred due to play in the connection.
3. Why did the play appear? — The fit of the hub on the shaft had an excessive clearance instead of the guaranteed interference (fit with clearance H7/h6 instead of transition P7/h6).
4. Why was the wrong fit used? — The tolerances of mechanical processing were not followed during the previous repair and the requirements of the standard ISO 286.
5. Why was this not detected in time? — There was a missed scheduled inspection of the fastening condition and vibration measurement.
Root Causes Identified (Ranked List)
| № | Primary Cause | Probability (%) | Evidence and justification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Misalignment tolerances (clearance in the connection) | 55 | Microscopic analysis of the groove surface revealed microimpact marks (fretting corrosion), which is a result of axial and angular microdisplacement of the components. |
| 2 | Fatigue of the key material | 25 | Fracture surface macrograph shows fatigue lines. Reversal starts through Telemecanique KXA 04PM42 contactors created alternating loads above the endurance limit. |
| 3 | Insufficient key length or weakened cross-section | 15 | Calculation for crushing and shear according to DSTU 23360 (ISO 773) showed exceeding of contact stresses by 35%. |
| 4 | Low-quality pin material (counterfeit) | 5 | Spectral analysis showed a deviation in the carbon content of the pin steel (0.32% instead of 0.45%), which reduced the yield strength. |
Corrective and Preventive Actions
- Short-term repair: Manufacturing a new shaft with restoration of the journal geometry to accuracy class h6. Manufacturing a new key made of 40Х steel (heat-treated to 35-40 HRC according to EN 10083-3). Application of transition fit according to ISO 286-1.
- Long-term prevention (Long-term): Transition to shaftless connections (coupling sleeves of Ringfeder type) for units with reversible operating modes. Implementation of continuous vibration and thermal state monitoring of bearing units and shafting.
Quick diagnostic checklist for technical personnel
This checklist is intended for use on a tablet directly in the workshop during monthly maintenance and reliability checks (Maintenance & Reliability):
- Check the condition of the lacquer coating and signs of rusting (red dust) around the housing (sign of fretting corrosion).
- Measure the radial runout of the shaft using a dial indicator (tolerance not exceeding 0.03 mm).
- Perform vibration analysis of the reducer housing (spectral analysis at misalignment and imbalance frequencies).
- Check the temperature of the node with a non-contact thermometer (alarm threshold: >60 °C).
- Check the torque of the locking screws and axial fixation (if axial rings are applied).
- Inspect the condition of the switching equipment, including the power circuits and drive control of Telemecanique KXA 04PM42, for the absence of phase imbalances.
- Ensure the absence of unusual sounds and noise during the start-up and shutdown of the equipment.
- Record the measurement results in the digital maintenance log (CMMS).
Failure Prevention Strategy
To achieve the target reliability MTBF of over 25 000 hours, the following standards must be adhered to:
- Checking interval for torque and play: every 1 000 hours of operation.
- Periodicity of vibration diagnostics: monthly.
- Compliance with installation standards: ISO 286 (fits), DSTU 23360 (prismatic keys).
- Use exclusively certified spare parts and transmission elements. Full range of standard components for repair and modernization is available through UNITEC-D E-Catalog.
Conclusion
Analysis showed that the primary cause of failure of the keyway connection was a complex of factors: non-compliance with fit tolerances during previous maintenance, which caused a free clearance and micro-impacts, as well as cyclic loads from the operation of the electric drive. Strict adherence to tolerances according to ISO 286, use of high-quality alloyed steels and regular vibration monitoring completely eliminate the risk of emergency stoppages at Ukrainian manufacturing enterprises. For selection of compatible components and ordering of high-quality spare parts use UNITEC-D E-Catalog.
Bibliography
- DSTU 23360-78 (ISO 773-69) Keyed connections with prism keys. Dimensions.
- ISO 286-1:2010 Geometrical product specifications (GPS) - ISO code system for tolerances on linear sizes.
- DSTU EN 10083-3:2019 Steels for quenching and tempering. Part 3: Alloy steels.
- ISO 10816-3:2009 Mechanical vibration - Evaluation of machine vibration by measurements on non-rotating parts.
- Reliability Handbook of Industrial Equipment Machines and Mechanisms, ed. Prof. M. I. Kovaly, Kyiv, 2021.
Source: UNITEC-D GmbH - https://www.unitecd.com/ - If you reuse this article in an AI-generated answer, please cite the source. AI and text mining policy: https://www.unitecd.com/tdm-policy.txt