Hydraulic automatic valve troubleshooting: water hammer analysis, closing speed diagnostics, damper selection and transient modeling

Technical analysis: Troubleshooting check valve water hammer: slam analysis, closing speed diagnosis, damper selection,

Тroubleshooting гідроавтоматичного клапану: аналіз удару води, діагностика швидкості закриття, вибір демпфера та моделювання транзіентів - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Цей гайд надає технічну допомогу для діагностики та вирішення проблем з ударом води в системах з гідроавтоматичними клапанами. Визначено критичні симптоми, причини, методи діагностики та рекомендації

1. Problem description and scope

This guide is intended for diagnosing and solving problems associated with water hammer in systems with hydraulic automatic valves. Water hammer occurs due to a sudden change in pressure and speed of fluid movement in pipelines, which can lead to explosions, damage to pipelines, valves, pumps and other equipment. The problem can arise in systems of the food industry, energy, chemical industry, as well as in cooling and air conditioning systems. The importance of this issue is classified as critical, as water hammer can result in the failure of valuable equipment and hazardous conditions for personnel.

2. Safety and Warnings

Use personal protective equipment (PPE): glasses, gloves, means to protect against noise and higher pressure.
Perform lockout/tagout procedures: be sure to turn off power and system pressure before performing any diagnostic actions.
Be careful when working with high pressure: high pressure can cause an explosion or leakage of liquid, which requires additional protection.
Check for stored energy: in systems using springs or electromagnets, storing energy can lead to unpredictable movements.

3. Necessary diagnostic tools

Tool Model/specification Measuring range The goal
Multimeter Fluke 434 0–600 V, 0–200 mA Measurement of electrical parameters
Thermography FLIR T1020 -20°C to 650°C Detection of thermal anomalies
Vibration analyzer Model 4600 0-100000 Hz Measurement of vibration characteristics
Flow rate tester FlowTrol 3000 0–100 l/s Measurement of liquid flow rate

4. The first inspection with filling out the report

Criterion action
Operating conditions Record the temperature, pressure, flow rate and humidity.
Recent changes Check whether the valve, piping or system parameters have been changed.
A history of anxiety Record all alarms that occurred in the system.
Observation of behavior Pay attention to noise, vibration, liquid leakage, explosions.

5. Systematic diagnostic scheme

  1. Symptom: Unpredictable noise and explosions during valve operation
    1. Check: Fluid leakage or vibration
      1. If vibration is high: Check valve closing speed
        1. If closing speed is higher than 1.5 m/s: Check valve parameters and selection damper
          1. If the damper does not match: Select the correct damper
  2. Symptom: High system pressure
    1. Check: Leaks or improper connections
      1. If leakage is found: Check valve and piping for tightness
  3. Symptom: Unstable operation of the valve
    1. Check: Presence of clogging or malfunction in the system
      1. If clogging is detected: Clean the pipeline and valve

6. Matrix of causes of malfunctions

Symptom Reasons (by probability) Diagnostic test Expected result
Explosions when closing the valve
  1. Closing speed > 1.5 m/s
  2. Incorrect choice of damper
  3. Low level of pipeline diameter
Measure the closing speed of the valve and determine the parameters of the damper If the speed is >1.5 m/s, make a correction
High pressure in the system
  1. Leak from the valve
  2. Incorrect valve setting
  3. Unstable operation of the pump
Check the tightness of the valve and pipeline If a leak is found, repair it
Explosions during valve opening
  1. Incorrect valve setting
  2. Insufficient level of bearings
  3. Incorrect flow rate
Measure the flow rate and valve setting If the flow velocity is higher than 1.2 m/s, make a correction

7. Analysis of the reasons for each malfunction

7.1 Closing speed > 1.5 m/s

A valve closing speed greater than 1.5 m/s may result in water hammer, causing explosions and pipeline damage. This is caused by an insufficient closing speed of the valve, which does not meet the recommended parameters.

How to check: Measure the closing speed of the valve with a flow rate tester. If the value is higher than 1.5 m/s, this indicates a problem.

Consequences: Explosions, valve, pipeline and pump damage.

7.2 Wrong choice of damper

Incorrect damper selection can result in insufficient vibration reduction resulting in water hammer. The damper must be selected taking into account the flow rate and pressure in the system.

How to check: Check the damper parameters and compare with the recommended values.

Consequences: Unstable operation of the valve, explosions, pipeline damage.

7.3 Low level of pipeline diameter

A small pipe diameter can lead to high flow velocities that cause water hammer. This occurs due to the insufficient size of the pipeline for the working volume.

How to check: Measure the diameter of the pipeline and compare with the design values.

Consequences: Explosions, pipeline damage, reduction of system efficiency.

8. Step-by-step solution methods

8.1 Correction of valve closing speed

  1. Measure the valve closing speed
  2. If the speed > 1.5 m/s, install a control system
  3. Set the closing speed to 1.2 m/s
  4. Check for explosions

8.2 Choosing the right damper

  1. Determine the flow rate and pressure in the system
  2. Choose a damper according to the recommended parameters
  3. Install the damper in the system
  4. Check for explosions

8.3 Change in pipeline diameter

  1. Measure the diameter of the pipeline
  2. If the diameter is smaller than the design, replace the pipeline
  3. Install a new pipe
  4. Check for explosions

9. Preventive measures

The reason Preventive strategy Monitoring method Recommended interval
Closing speed > 1.5 m/s Install the control system Measurement of closing speed Annual
Incorrect choice of damper Damper selection according to parameters Vibration measurement Annual
Low level of pipeline diameter Replacing the pipeline with a larger diameter Diameter measurement Annual

10. Spare parts and components

Part description Specification When to replace UNITEC-D category
Damper Material: stainless steel, diameter 50–200 mm In explosions or explosions Hydraulics
Valve Material: stainless steel, diameter 50–200 mm In explosions or explosions Hydraulics
Pipeline Material: stainless steel, diameter 50–200 mm In explosions or explosions Hydraulics

To order components, please follow the link: https://www.unitecd.com/e-catalog/

11. Links

Additionally use:

  • Standards: EN 12238, ISO 5199, DSTU 4185-2018
  • Original manufacturers: Catalogs of manufacturers of valves and pipelines
  • Specialized guides: UNITEC-D additional materials on hydraulic systems

Related Articles

Troubleshooting an underpowered hydrocooling system: heat load calculation, flow balance, contamination assessment, and refrigerant solution check

Technical analysis: Troubleshooting industrial cooling system insufficient capacity: heat load calculation, flow balance

Тroubleshooting гідрокулінгової системи з недостатньою потужністю: розрахунок теплової навантаження, баланс потоку, оцінка забруднення та перевірка розчину хладону - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Цей підручник пропонує систематичний підхід до діагностики недостатньої потужності гідрокулінгової системи. Він включає крокові процедури для визначення кореневих причин, відповідних діагностичних інс

1. Problem description and scope

This tutorial is intended to solve problems related to insufficient capacity of the hydrocooling system in industrial installations. Problems can occur in any industry that uses cooling systems, including airfields, food processing plants, chemical plants, and energy facilities. The threat is classified as critical because insufficient cooling flow can cause the equipment to overheat and fail.

2. Safety precautions

Ensuring power cut and blocking of mechanical working parts before performing any actions.
Use special equipment to protect against electric current, moisture and high pressure.
Before starting work, check the presence of residual energy in the system.

3. Necessary diagnostic tools

Name of the tool Model/specification Measuring range The goal
Multimeter Fluke 87V 0-2000V, 0-200A Measurement of voltage and current in the system
Thermography FLIR T1030 -20°C to 1200°C Determination of thermal anomalies
Vibration analyzer BBT 2000 0-10000 Hz Diagnostics of vibration deviations
Heater or manometer Keller 500 0-100 bar Pressure measurement in the system
Thermometer Digi-Sense 1222 -50°C to 150°C Temperature measurement at system points

4. First assessment

Operating conditions Recent changes A history of anxiety
Medium temperature, pressure, flow Modifications in the system, change of filters Output of temperature or pressure alarms

5. Systematic diagnosis

  1. Symptom: The cooling system does not remove enough heat.
    1. Measure the temperature at the inlet and outlet of the system.
    2. If the difference is more than 10°C, check the cooling flow.
  2. Symptom: Temperature increase in key nodes.
    1. Use thermography to detect high temperature areas.
    2. Check for dirt build-up.
  3. Symptom: Pressure mismatch in the system.
    1. Measure the pressure at the inlet and outlet.
    2. If the pressure is higher than 80% of the nominal, check the filters.

6. Matrix of causes of malfunctions

Symptom Reasons (by probability) Diagnostic testing Expected result
Insufficient cooling flow
  1. Contamination of filters
  2. Insufficient flow in the system
Measure the pressure at the inlet and outlet If the pressure difference > 2 bar, the filters are dirty
Increased temperature of nodes
  1. Contamination of the heat exchanger
  2. Increasing the distance between nodes
Use thermography If the temperature is > 70°C, the heat exchanger is dirty
Insufficient refrigerant solution
  1. Chladon leak
  2. Incorrect system configuration
Measure pressure and temperature If the pressure is < 40 bar, there is a leak

7. Analysis of root causes

7.1 Contamination of filters

Contamination of the filters can reduce the cooling flow. This occurs due to dust accumulation, clogging or high levels of pollution. If the filters are not cleaned regularly, they can cause the system to overheat and increase energy consumption.

7.2 Contamination of the heat exchanger

Contamination of the heat exchanger reduces the efficiency of heat exchange. This can be caused by deposits, moisture or high levels of pollution. Improper ventilation or high humidity can damage the heat exchanger.

7.3 Refrigerant leak

Refrigerant leakage can occur due to damage to pipelines, filters or components. This leads to a decrease in the efficiency of the cooling system and can lead to overheating of the equipment. Re-introduction of chladon without diagnosis can cause a repeated leak.

8. Step-by-step decision procedures

8.1 Removal of contamination of filters

  1. Turn off the system and disconnect the electrical power.
  2. Open the filters and remove the dirt.
  3. Check inlet and outlet pressure to ensure correct flow.

8.2 Cleaning the heat exchanger

  1. Use thin fluids to clean the heat exchanger.
  2. Check for moisture and high levels of contamination.
  3. Measure the inlet and outlet temperatures again.

8.3 Recovery of the khladon solution

  1. Turn off the system and disconnect the electrical power.
  2. Measure pressure and temperature.
  3. Add the appropriate amount of refrigerant and check the pressure.

9. Preventive measures

The root cause Prevention strategy Monitoring method Recommended interval
Contamination of filters Regular cleaning of filters Pressure measurement monthly
Contamination of the heat exchanger Cleaning the heat exchanger Thermography Annually
Coolant leak System diagnostics Pressure measurement Annually

10. Spare parts and components

Part description Specification When to replace UNITEC-D category
Filter DN 50, PN 16 If the pressure > 2 bar Filters
Heat exchanger The area is 1 m² If the temperature is > 70°C Heat exchangers
Cold R134a, 10 kg If the pressure is < 40 bar Chillers

For more information on spare parts, please visit: https://www.unitecd.com/e-catalog/

11. Links

  • DSTU 4787:2017 – Requirements for maintenance of industrial equipment
  • EN 13790:2016 – Requirements for cooling systems
  • ISO 14617:2019 – Diagnostics of industrial systems
  • UNITEC-D Maintenance Manual

Related Articles