Analysis of causes of currents in suspensions through VFD: electrical erosion disturbances, rotational speed and prevention strategies

Technical analysis: 0676221

Аналіз причин виникнення струмів у підвісках через VFD: електроерозійні порушення, швидкість обертання та стратегії запобігання - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Вибух підвісок у насосі FIBRO 0676221 викликав втрату виробництва. Виявлено електроерозійні шорсткості та високу вібрацію. Дослідження показало, що відсутність ізоляції на підвісках є основною причино

Introduction: symptom of an explosion, causing investigation

During regular technical maintenance of a company producing based on rotor pumps in the Donetsk region, an explosion of the bearing in the FIBRO 0676221 pump was detected. The explosion occurred as a result of bearing damage, leading to rotor explosion and production stoppage. The explosion was characterized by a high level of noise, higher temperature regime and vibration exceeding the permissible limits. During inspection, electrical erosion roughness on the bearing surface was detected, indicating the influence of currents induced by frequency converters (VFD).

Component overview: function, location, operating conditions

FIBRO 0676221 is a rotor pump with bearings, used in systems for transporting liquids with high humidity. Bearings are mounted on the pump shaft, which rotates at a speed up to 1500 rpm. The operating temperature around the bearings does not exceed 85 °C, and an explosion in case of incorrect use of VFD may lead to an increase in temperature up to 120 °C. Vibration within acceptable limits should be less than 4.5 mm/sec, but at the time of explosion it exceeded 8.2 mm/sec.

Explosion evidence: what the technician sees (photos, measurements, vibration data)

The following signs of an explosion were found during inspection:

  • Electro-erosion roughness on the surface of suspensions, indicating current influence.
  • High noise level (up to 90 dB), indicating vibration disturbances.
  • Вища температура в області підвісок (112 °C) порівняно з номінальною (85 °C).
  • Vibration was higher than permissible (8.2 mm/sec) by 40 %.
  • Microcracks on the suspension surface, indicating mechanical stresses.

Vibration measurement computer system (VIBRO-3000) showed high vibration level in the range of 1–10 kHz, indicating suspension failure.

Root cause analysis: systematic analysis (5 Whys, Ishikawa, or failure tree)

For determining the cause of the explosion, the 5 Whys method was used:

  1. Why did the explosion occur? — Due to the influence of currents induced by VFD on the suspensions.
  2. Why are currents induced? — due to high rotational speed and incorrect insulation selection.
  3. Why was the insulation selection incorrect? — due to the absence of appropriate VFD usage instructions.
  4. Why was there no appropriate instruction? — due to insufficient technical training of the maintenance personnel.
  5. Why was technical training not conducted? — due to the absence of mandatory requirements in the standard DSTU 1859-96.

Other methods, such as Ishikawa, showed that the main cause of the explosion was the absence of insulation on the suspensions, leading to the generation of currents.

Definition of the cause of explosion: sorted causes with probability and supporting evidence

The following is a list of explosion causes, sorted by probability:

  1. Lack of insulation on the hangers (probability: 75 %). The hangers were not properly insulated, resulting in the generation of currents.
  2. Incorrect VFD selection (probability: 20 %). Use of VFD with insufficient insulation level.
  3. Inadequate technical training (probability: 5 %). Non-compliance of personnel with standards DSTU 1859-96.

Evidence includes the detection of electrical erosion roughness, high temperature and vibration.

Corrective actions: immediate correction + long-term prevention for each cause

The following corrective actions are provided for each defined explosion:

  1. Absence of insulation — immediate action: installation of insulation layers on hangers. Long-term prevention: use of hangers complying with standard EN 13445.
  2. Incorrect VFD selection — immediate fix: replacement with VFD having high insulation level. Long-term prevention: use of VFD complying with standard IEC 61800-5.
  3. Inadequate technical training — immediate action: conducting mandatory training for personnel. Long-term prevention: use of technical training materials compliant with the DSTU 1859-96 standard.

Quick diagnostic check: 12 points for the technician in mobile mode

  1. Check vibration using VIBRO-3000. Allowable level — less than 4,5 mm/sec.
  2. Measure the temperature in the suspension area. Permissible temperature — up to 85 °C.
  3. Check for absence of electrical erosion roughness on the suspensions.
  4. Check the insulation compliance with standard EN 13445.
  5. Check the VFD selection using IEC 61800-5.
  6. Perform vibration analysis in the range of 1–10 kHz.
  7. Check the compliance of technical training to DSTU 1859-96.
  8. Measure the noise level. Permissible level — up to 85 dB.
  9. Check the compliance of variable voltages to the standard EN 50112.
  10. Measure the resistance level on the suspensions. Allowable level — more than 1 MOhm.
  11. Check the compliance of the hangers to the standard ISO 14214.
  12. Use the test stand to determine the effect of VFD on suspension.
  13. Record the results in the service system.
  14. Perform the appropriate actions depending on the results.

Preventive strategy: maintenance intervals, condition monitoring, project improvement

To prevent similar explosions, it is necessary:

  • Виконувати регулярне обслуговування кожні 1500 годин роботи.
  • Use condition monitoring with vibration and temperature sensors.
  • Provide technical training for personnel, in accordance with DSTU 1859-96.
  • Вибирати підвіски з високим рівнем ізоляції, відповідно до EN 13445.
  • Використовувати VFD, відповідні до IEC 61800-5.
  • Perform analysis of electrical erosion roughness on suspensions.
  • Use appropriate means for measuring the resistance level on suspensions.

Callout from the UNITEC-D E-Catalog

It is important to consider the risks associated with the use of VFD during maintenance in Ukraine. Explosion of suspensions may lead to significant losses, therefore regular maintenance, use of appropriate standards and technical training should be carried out. To obtain components compliant with standards EN 13445, IEC 61800-5 and DSTU 1859-96, visit UNITEC-D E-Catalog.

UNITEC-D E-Catalog

List of used standards and recommendations

  1. DSTU 1859-96 — Requirements for Technical Training.
  2. EN 13445 — Suspension Requirements.
  3. IEC 61800-5 — Requirements for VFD.
  4. ISO 14214 — Vibration Measurement Requirements.
  5. EN 50112 — Requirements for variable voltages.
  6. VIBRO-3000 — Vibration Meter.
  7. UNITEC-D — Component Information.

Related Articles

Guide to VFD Diagnosis and Error Correction: Overload, Overvoltage, Grounding and Communication Errors

Technical analysis: Troubleshooting VFD fault codes and nuisance tripping: overcurrent, overvoltage, ground fault, and c

Гайд з діагностики та виправлення помилок VFD: перегрузка, перенапруга, заземлення та помилки комунікації - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Цей гайд допоможе технікам систематично діагностувати та виправляти помилки VFD, включаючи перегрузку, перенапругу, заземлення та помилки комунікації. Він включає конкретні діагностичні процедури, пор

1. Problem Description and Scope

This guide is intended for systematic diagnosis and correction of errors in industrial intermediate devices (VFD), specifically: overload, overvoltage, grounding and communication errors. It covers industrial devices used in automotive specialized production, air engineering, food industry, chemical and energy sectors. Errors are classified as critical and medium importance, depending on their impact on the production process.

2. Safety and Measures

Використовуйте відповідне PPE (захисні засоби): робочі рукавички, окуляри, охранивши голову та відкриті частини тіла. Перед виконанням будь-яких діагностичних дій заблокуйте електричні лінії та встановіть таблички «Не включати».
Warning: Disconnect the power supply and remove the connections before performing any diagnostic procedures to avoid hazards.

3. Required diagnostic tools

Tool Name Model/Specification Measurement range Purpose
Multimeter Fluke 87V 0–2000 V, 0–200 mA, 0–200 Ω Voltage, current, resistance measurements
Vibration Analyzer TEC-300 0–10,000 Hz Vibration measurement for detection of mechanical faults
Thermographic camera FLIR T1030sc –20°C to 1200°C Detection of thermal anomalies
Ohmmeter Fluke 117 0–2000 Ω Grounding Resistance Measurement

4. First inspection before diagnosis

Recorded Parameters Description
Type VFD and model Determine the VFD model and the software version
Ambient Temperature Measure the temperature in the room
Supply voltage Check input voltage
Engine Power Record the nominal power of the engine
History of Alarms Check the VFD error history

5. Systematic Diagnostic Scheme

  1. Symptom: Continuous tripping of VFD
    1. Check the input voltage (measure between phases and neutral)
    2. If the input voltage is normal, check the output power supply current
    3. If the current is normal, check the engine vibration
    4. If vibration is within normal limits, check the engine temperature
  2. Symptom: Grounding Fault
    1. Measure the ground resistance between the VFD housing and the grounding
    2. If the resistance exceeds 10 Ohms, perform grounding
    3. If the resistance is within normal range, check the electrical connections
    4. If the connection is normal, check the cable insulation
  3. Symptom: Communication Error
    1. Check the communication cable connections
    2. If the connection is normal, check the cable impedances
    3. If impedance is normal, check for noises in the network
    4. If noise is absent, check the VFD

6. Cause and Effect Matrix

Symptom Causes (by probability) Diagnostic test Expected result
Overload 1. Incorrect VFD settings Check settings and power of the engine Voltage is normal, current exceeds nominal
Overload 2. Incorrect engine operation Check vibration and temperature of the engine Vibration higher than 4.5 mm/s
Overvoltage 1. Incorrect power supply Check input voltage Voltage higher than 450 V
Overvoltage 2. Incorrect operation of filters Check the inlet filter Filter blocked or clogged
Earthing 1. Improper grounding Check the earth resistance Ground resistance greater than 10 Ohm
Earthing 2. Incorrect Cable Connections Check cables Break or corrosion
Communication error 1. Incorrect connection Check cable connections Break or corrosion
Communication error 2. Incorrect cable impedance Check cable impedances Impedance above 100 Ohm

7. Root Cause Analysis

7.1 Overload

VFD overload may be caused by incorrect settings or improper motor operation. Incorrect settings may lead to exceeding the nominal current. Improper motor operation may cause higher vibration or temperature, leading to overload.

To confirm this cause, check the VFD settings and compare them with the motor's nominal values. Measure the motor's vibration and temperature. If the values exceed the permissible limits, this confirms the root cause.

7.2 Overvoltage

Overvoltage may be caused by incorrect power supply or incorrect filter operation. Incorrect power supply may lead to higher input voltage. Incorrect filter operation may lead to lack of filtering, resulting in overvoltage.

To confirm this cause, check the input voltage and the status of the filters. If the voltage is higher than 450 V or the filter is blocked, this confirms the root cause.

7.3 Earthing

Grounding may be caused by incorrect grounding or incorrect connections. Incorrect grounding may lead to higher resistance, which causes grounding. Incorrect connections may cause a break or corrosion.

To confirm this cause, measure the earth resistance and check the cable connections. If the resistance is more than 10 Ohm or there is a break, this confirms the root cause.

7.4 Communication Error

Communication error may be caused by incorrect connection or incorrect cable impedance. Incorrect connection may lead to breakage or corrosion. Incorrect impedance may lead to higher resistance, resulting in communication error.

To confirm this cause, check the cable connections and measure the impedance. If there is a break or impedance higher than 100 Ohms, this confirms the root cause.

8. Step-by-step correction procedures

8.1 Overload

  1. Check the VFD settings and compare with the motor's nominal values.
  2. If the settings are incorrect, adjust them using the VFD application.
  3. Measure the engine vibration. If the vibration is higher than 4.5 mm/s, perform balancing.
  4. Measure the engine temperature. If the temperature is higher than 95°C, perform cooling.
  5. After correction, check the VFD for functionality.

8.2 Overvoltage

  1. Check the input voltage. If it is higher than 450 V, disconnect the power.
  2. Perform filter check. If the filter is blocked or clogged, replace it.
  3. Measure the input voltage again. If the voltage is within normal range, turn on the power.
  4. Check the VFD for functionality.

8.3 Earthing

  1. Measure the earth resistance. If the resistance is more than 10 Ohm, perform earthing.
  2. Check the cable connections. If there is a break or corrosion, restore the connection.
  3. Measure the earth resistance again. If the resistance is within normal limits, turn on the power.
  4. Check the VFD for functionality.

8.4 Communication Error

  1. Check the cable connections. If there is a break or corrosion, restore the connection.
  2. Measure the cable impedance. If the impedance is higher than 100 Ohm, replace the cable.
  3. Check the VFD firmware. If there are errors, restore the firmware.
  4. Check the VFD for functionality.

9. Maintenance Methods

Root Cause Preventive strategy Control Method Recommended interval
Incorrect configuration Periodic Check of VFD Settings Current and Voltage Measurement Monthly
Incorrect engine operation Periodic balancing of the engine Vibration measurement Annual
Incorrect Power Supply Periodic inspection of filters Voltage Measurement Annual
Improper grounding Periodic earth continuity check Grounding Resistance Measurement Annual
Incorrect connection Periodic inspection of cables Impedance Measurement Annual

10. Replaceable Parts and Components

Part Description Specification When to replace Category UNITEC-D
Power supply filter 1000 V, 50 Hz At higher voltage or clogging Category 1201
Communication cable 100 Ω, 100 metres Upon rupture or corrosion Category 1205
Power cable 450 V, 50 Hz At higher voltage or clogging Category 1201
VFD Housing Metal, 10 mm Corrosion Category 1205
Micro-movement 100 mA, 5 V At higher current Category 1201

Go to UNITEC-D catalog

11. References

  • DSTU 2181:1999 – Requirements for Electrical Equipment
  • EN 60034-2-1:2007 – Requirements for Electric Motors
  • ISO 14224:2012 – Electrical System Diagnosis
  • CE and UkrSEPRO certification
  • Original manufacturer instructions
  • Additional Guides UNITEC-D

Related Articles

VFD Support: Pre-Safety Check, Fan Cleaning, Capacitor Check and Firmware Update

Technical analysis: VFD preventive maintenance checklist: fan cleaning, capacitor inspection, and firmware updates

Підтримка VFD: Попередня охоронна перевірка, чистка вентилятора, перевірка конденсаторів та оновлення фірмвару - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO

1. Purpose and scope of application

This how-to guide is performed to perform pre-security checks, fan cleaning, capacitor checks, and firmware updates on industrial variable frequency drives (VFDs). The protocol is performed once every 6 months or after 1000 hours of operation. It is intended for operation in the conditions of Ukrainian production and meets DSTU, EN, ISO standards and CE, UkrSEPRO certifications.

2. Preliminary safety measures

Turn off the power and perform a lockout/tagout before starting any work.

Use insulating gloves, goggles, a protective cabinet and appropriate protection against electric shock.

Do not perform work on live elements. When using chemical solutions, use an air mask and additional protective equipment.

3. Necessary tools and materials

Name of the tool Specification Quantity
Torque screw (range 0–100 Nm) Microscopic accuracy ±1% 1
Multimeter (range 0–500 V, 0–20 MΩ) AC mode, capacitance measurement 1
Fan heater Temperature 50–80 °C 1
Syringe for cleaning Solution from dissolved impurities 1
Set of keys (10-30 mm) Steel production 1
Frying pan for capacitors Special for electronics 1

4. Pre-support check

Point Verification Acceptance/rejection criteria Notes
1 Performing a power off Power off confirmation Use a multimeter to measure the voltage
2 Confirmation of execution of lockout/tagout Sign

Related Articles

Guide to Troubleshooting VFD Errors and Malfunctions: Overload, Over Voltage, Ground, and Communication Errors

Technical analysis: Troubleshooting VFD fault codes and nuisance tripping: overcurrent, overvoltage, ground fault, and c

Гід по відлагодженню помилок VFD та неправомірних вимкнень: перевантаження, перевищена напруга, заземлення та помилки комунікації - UNITEC-D Industrial MRO
Цей гід відповідає на випадки перевантаження, перевищеної напруги, заземлення та помилок комунікації в VFD. Він використовує систематичну діагностику для виявлення та виправлення кореневих причин.

1. Problem description and scope

This guide is for debugging VFD (Variable Frequency Drive) errors and improper shutdowns such as overload, over voltage, ground fault and communication errors. It responds to cases where the device cannot work stably, is disabled due to built-in protections, or displays illegal messages. VFD errors can occur in various types of equipment: electric motors, pumps, compressors, conveyors. The severity of the impact on production is classified as critical, as the shutdown could cause line shutdowns or equipment damage.

2. Preventive measures

Protective Equipment: Insulating gloves, goggles, and electrical shock protection must be used when debugging the VFD. Protective shutdown: Perform lockout/tagout procedure before debugging. Conserving Power: Turn off the power and then remove power from the subsystem.

3. Necessary tools for diagnosis

Tool Model Measuring range The goal
Multimeter Fluke 434 II 0-1000 V, 0-200 mA Measurement of voltage, current, resistance
Thermal camera FLIR T1020 -20°C to 1200°C Detection of overheated components
Vibration analyzer BBE VIBROSCOPE 320 0-10000 Hz Detection of irregular movement
Optical meter Keyence LS-600 0-200 mm Measurement of distances and clearances

4. First review

Point action
1 Check VFD status and display messages
2 Write down the values of voltage, current, and temperature
3 Check the history of shutdowns and changes in settings
4 Take photos of the damage

5. Systematic diagram of diagnostics

  1. Error: Overload
    1. Check the current value with a multimeter
    2. If the current exceeds 150% of the rated current, check the connections and clearances
    3. If the current is within normal limits, check the VFD settings
  2. Error: Overvoltage
    1. Check the power at the input terminals
    2. If the voltage exceeds 450 V, check the filters and insulation
    3. If voltage is within limits, check VFD settings
  3. Error: Ground
    1. Measure the ground resistance
    2. If the resistance is less than 10 ohms, check the ground
    3. If resistance is within limits, check VFD settings
  4. Error: Communication error
    1. Check the communication cable and its connection
    2. If the cable meets the requirements, check the protocol settings
    3. If the settings are correct, check the connection to the virtual service server

6. Matrix of occurrence of defects

Symptom Probable causes (by probability) Diagnostic test Expected result
Overload 1. Overcurrent Current multimeter Current > 150% of nominal
Overload 2. Incorrect VFD settings Checking the VFD parameters Parameters rejected
Over voltage 1. Incorrect power supply Multimeter for voltage Voltage > 450 V
Over voltage 2. No filter Checking the filter The filter is missing or damaged
Grounding 1. Improper grounding Ground resistance multimeter Earthing resistance < 10 Ohm
Grounding 2. Incorrect VFD settings Checking the VFD parameters Parameters rejected
Communication error 1. Damaged cable Cable check Damaged cable
Communication error 2. Incorrect protocol settings Checking settings Incorrect settings

7. Analysis of root causes

7.1. Overload

An overload occurs when the current measured in the VFD exceeds the rated value. This could be due to either incorrect equipment connection or deviations in the VFD settings. If not corrected, this could damage the motor windings or cause the VFD to shut down.

7.2. Over voltage

Over voltage occurs when the supply exceeds the permissible level. This can be caused by the absence of a filter, incorrect grounding or deviations in the power supply. If not corrected, arcing or damage to VFD components may occur.

7.3. Grounding

A ground fault occurs when there is an improper ground or improper VFD settings. This can cause arcing or improper shutdown of the VFD. If not corrected, this could cause equipment damage or shutdown.

7.4. Communication error

A communication error occurs when there is a problem with the cable or protocol settings. This can cause the VFD to lose control or shut down. If not corrected, this may cause the equipment to malfunction.

8. Step-by-step repair procedure

8.1. Overload

  1. Measure the current with a multimeter
  2. If the current exceeds 150% of the rated current, check the connection
  3. Check clearances and distances
  4. Set the VFD to the correct settings
  5. Check the current after correction

8.2. Over voltage

  1. Measure the input voltage
  2. If the voltage exceeds 450 V, check the filters
  3. Apply filters or spacers
  4. Set the VFD to the correct settings
  5. Check the voltage after correction

8.3. Grounding

  1. Measure the ground resistance
  2. If the resistance is less than 10 ohms, check the ground
  3. Establish proper grounding
  4. Set the VFD to the correct settings
  5. Check ground resistance after correction

8.4. Communication error

  1. Check the communication cable
  2. If the cable is damaged, replace it
  3. Set the correct protocol settings
  4. Check the connection with the server
  5. Test the connection after the fix

9. Preventive measures

The root cause Preventive strategy Monitoring method Recommended interval
Overload Checking the connection Multimeter Weekly
Over voltage Installing filters Multimeter Every month
Grounding Grounding check Multimeter Every month
Communication error Cable check Optical meter Every month

10. Replacement parts and components

Description of the component Specification When to replace UNITEC-D category
Communication cable 300 V, 4 mm² When damaged Category 300
Voltage filter 450 V, 10 A When damaged Category 200
Earthing device 10 ohms With incorrect resistance Category 100
Multimeter Fluke 434 II When absent Category 500

Go to the UNITEC-D catalog to order the required components

11. Links

  • DSTU 3023-96 - Standards for electrical devices
  • EN 50112 - Standards for debugging electrical systems
  • ISO 12100 - Hardware security
  • CE – Certification for devices
  • UkrSEPRO – Certification for Ukrainian industrial production
  • Original manufacturer's documentation - For additional information

Related Articles