Introduction: symptom of an explosion, causing investigation
During regular technical maintenance of a company producing based on rotor pumps in the Donetsk region, an explosion of the bearing in the FIBRO 0676221 pump was detected. The explosion occurred as a result of bearing damage, leading to rotor explosion and production stoppage. The explosion was characterized by a high level of noise, higher temperature regime and vibration exceeding the permissible limits. During inspection, electrical erosion roughness on the bearing surface was detected, indicating the influence of currents induced by frequency converters (VFD).
Component overview: function, location, operating conditions
FIBRO 0676221 is a rotor pump with bearings, used in systems for transporting liquids with high humidity. Bearings are mounted on the pump shaft, which rotates at a speed up to 1500 rpm. The operating temperature around the bearings does not exceed 85 °C, and an explosion in case of incorrect use of VFD may lead to an increase in temperature up to 120 °C. Vibration within acceptable limits should be less than 4.5 mm/sec, but at the time of explosion it exceeded 8.2 mm/sec.
Explosion evidence: what the technician sees (photos, measurements, vibration data)
The following signs of an explosion were found during inspection:
- Electro-erosion roughness on the surface of suspensions, indicating current influence.
- High noise level (up to 90 dB), indicating vibration disturbances.
- Вища температура в області підвісок (112 °C) порівняно з номінальною (85 °C).
- Vibration was higher than permissible (8.2 mm/sec) by 40 %.
- Microcracks on the suspension surface, indicating mechanical stresses.
Vibration measurement computer system (VIBRO-3000) showed high vibration level in the range of 1–10 kHz, indicating suspension failure.
Root cause analysis: systematic analysis (5 Whys, Ishikawa, or failure tree)
For determining the cause of the explosion, the 5 Whys method was used:
- Why did the explosion occur? — Due to the influence of currents induced by VFD on the suspensions.
- Why are currents induced? — due to high rotational speed and incorrect insulation selection.
- Why was the insulation selection incorrect? — due to the absence of appropriate VFD usage instructions.
- Why was there no appropriate instruction? — due to insufficient technical training of the maintenance personnel.
- Why was technical training not conducted? — due to the absence of mandatory requirements in the standard DSTU 1859-96.
Other methods, such as Ishikawa, showed that the main cause of the explosion was the absence of insulation on the suspensions, leading to the generation of currents.
Definition of the cause of explosion: sorted causes with probability and supporting evidence
The following is a list of explosion causes, sorted by probability:
- Lack of insulation on the hangers (probability: 75 %). The hangers were not properly insulated, resulting in the generation of currents.
- Incorrect VFD selection (probability: 20 %). Use of VFD with insufficient insulation level.
- Inadequate technical training (probability: 5 %). Non-compliance of personnel with standards DSTU 1859-96.
Evidence includes the detection of electrical erosion roughness, high temperature and vibration.
Corrective actions: immediate correction + long-term prevention for each cause
The following corrective actions are provided for each defined explosion:
- Absence of insulation — immediate action: installation of insulation layers on hangers. Long-term prevention: use of hangers complying with standard EN 13445.
- Incorrect VFD selection — immediate fix: replacement with VFD having high insulation level. Long-term prevention: use of VFD complying with standard IEC 61800-5.
- Inadequate technical training — immediate action: conducting mandatory training for personnel. Long-term prevention: use of technical training materials compliant with the DSTU 1859-96 standard.
Quick diagnostic check: 12 points for the technician in mobile mode
- Check vibration using VIBRO-3000. Allowable level — less than 4,5 mm/sec.
- Measure the temperature in the suspension area. Permissible temperature — up to 85 °C.
- Check for absence of electrical erosion roughness on the suspensions.
- Check the insulation compliance with standard EN 13445.
- Check the VFD selection using IEC 61800-5.
- Perform vibration analysis in the range of 1–10 kHz.
- Check the compliance of technical training to DSTU 1859-96.
- Measure the noise level. Permissible level — up to 85 dB.
- Check the compliance of variable voltages to the standard EN 50112.
- Measure the resistance level on the suspensions. Allowable level — more than 1 MOhm.
- Check the compliance of the hangers to the standard ISO 14214.
- Use the test stand to determine the effect of VFD on suspension.
- Record the results in the service system.
- Perform the appropriate actions depending on the results.
Preventive strategy: maintenance intervals, condition monitoring, project improvement
To prevent similar explosions, it is necessary:
- Виконувати регулярне обслуговування кожні 1500 годин роботи.
- Use condition monitoring with vibration and temperature sensors.
- Provide technical training for personnel, in accordance with DSTU 1859-96.
- Вибирати підвіски з високим рівнем ізоляції, відповідно до EN 13445.
- Використовувати VFD, відповідні до IEC 61800-5.
- Perform analysis of electrical erosion roughness on suspensions.
- Use appropriate means for measuring the resistance level on suspensions.
Callout from the UNITEC-D E-Catalog
It is important to consider the risks associated with the use of VFD during maintenance in Ukraine. Explosion of suspensions may lead to significant losses, therefore regular maintenance, use of appropriate standards and technical training should be carried out. To obtain components compliant with standards EN 13445, IEC 61800-5 and DSTU 1859-96, visit UNITEC-D E-Catalog.
List of used standards and recommendations
- DSTU 1859-96 — Requirements for Technical Training.
- EN 13445 — Suspension Requirements.
- IEC 61800-5 — Requirements for VFD.
- ISO 14214 — Vibration Measurement Requirements.
- EN 50112 — Requirements for variable voltages.
- VIBRO-3000 — Vibration Meter.
- UNITEC-D — Component Information.